'If they had listened, Baby P would still be alive'

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, December 06, 2008
Profile image for This is SouthWales

This is SouthWales

THE father of a murdered Swansea child has called for more government funding to protect children such as tragic London toddler "Baby P".

Gareth Gilbert says the notorious case of the 17-month-old from Hackney, who died after being abused by his mother and two other men, brought back nightmarish memories of the loss of his own son, Aaron.

The 13-month-year-old baby died at his Townhill home in 2005 after being repeatedly hit by his mother's new lover, Andrew Lloyd, who left him with 50 injuries to his body.

Lloyd, aged 23, at the time of his conviction, is serving 24 years in jail, while Aaron's mother Rebecca Lewis was jailed for six years after creating legal history in the UK by being convicted of familial homicide, because she failed to prevent Lloyd from killing her son.

Meanwhile, Gareth Gilbert says the case of Baby P has reopened raw feelings, as have plans for a memorial walk in his name through Llanelli next weekend.

The 28-year-old said: "Why was there nothing like that down here?

"I don't want to disrespect Baby P in any way at all, but there have been other babies who have lost their lives through abuse and neglect.

"The Government needs to make more money available to protect the welfare of children."

Mr Gilbert, from Gendros, has found some happiness since the loss of his son, with a new relationship.

And 18 months ago he and partner Barbara-Ann celebrated the birth of their son McKenzie.

But despite their joy, Mr Gilbert still suffers from bouts of depression which have hampered his attempts to get back to work.

And he says he wants to know whether Swansea's Safeguarding Children Board, which looked into Aaron's death, have implemented recommendations made after a review of his son's case.

"When my son was murdered it made legal history," he said.

"I would like to find out if anything has changed in Social Services.

"Why was no-one there named and shamed like in Baby P's case?"

A spokesman for Swansea Local Safeguarding Children Board said a serious case review was carried out following the death of Aaron Gilbert, and Mr Gilbert had been invited to a meeting with the board chairman to discuss it.

And he said the agencies involved have since acted on its recommendations.

"All the recommendations have been acted upon and measures have been put in place which include increasing staff numbers and improved oversight of casework," he said.

"The serious case review into Aaron's death was a frank, honest and independent assessment of the involvement of all the agencies involved in the case and the lessons they need to learn.

"It made a number of recommendations for each of the agencies to strengthen safeguards to identify vulnerable children and individuals who pose a risk to them, and this has resulted in measures such as improved procedures on the part of all the agencies.

"But it did also point out that the majority of the circumstances which led to Aaron's death could not have been known or predicted, and that many of the safeguards put in place to identify vulnerable children did work effectively."

Neath Port Talbot Council's head of children and young people's services, Julie Rzezniczek, said: "The Assembly Government has written to all Welsh local authorities requesting them to evaluate the effectiveness of local arrangements to safeguard and promote the welfare of children, and to report on this to the Assembly by Monday, February 2.

"We will be complying with this request."

Jake Morgan, head of children's services at Carmarthenshire Council, said: "The council is keen to ensure that all children are protected.

"As a learning organisation, we always look closely at any tragedies such as that of the Baby P case to see if there are any lessons we can learn to further improve our practice.

"Child protection work in Carmarthenshire is generally recognised as of good quality with the Commission for Social Services in Wales recently finding that alongside 'strong leadership and management' of the social work service for children, there was also 'good child protection work with clear outcomes and related service inputs'."

He added: "Carmarthenshire Council is among the best in Wales at recruiting and training social work staff.

"Despite this, our Local Children's Safeguarding board will look specifically at the Baby P case to ensure our services and processes continue to be as robust as they can be in protecting children."

8
Tweet this article
Report

8 Comments

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by JOHN, dalry

    Monday, December 08 2008, 5:22PM

    “Decisions are often made by senior social workers against the opinions of those in direct contact. In such circumstances the latter should be prosecuted if their decisions are faulty.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Blod, Wales

    Monday, December 08 2008, 12:23PM

    “No point trying to blame social workers, councils or the government - only THE PARENTS are to blame.
    You have to have a licence to own a TV but anyone can have as many kids as they like whether they are fit parents or not. Look at Karen Matthews!
    Yet they all plead that THEY are the victims never do they take RESPONSIBILITY.
    This underclass in society truly sickens me.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Jane, Swansea

    Sunday, December 07 2008, 8:43PM

    “Once you made social work an academic study rather than a job for people with common sense, it was sadly rather inevitable that these tragic deaths should start happening. The blame and sue culture has tied the hands of anyone working directly with members of the public. These two factors might be partly to blame for failure to stop these deaths. But ultimately the parents are to blame.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by evans, carmarthen

    Sunday, December 07 2008, 6:36PM

    “A proper inquiry needs to be held into the tragic and needles death of this baby/toddler and the father who warned that a Victoria Climbie type death in Swansea a few months before Aaron's death should be invited to give evidence to the Inquiry. As those in position know the people who were warned are still in their jobs. they ignored the warnings!”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by nessa, uk

    Sunday, December 07 2008, 5:46PM

    “i feel so sorry for baby p if i was his mam i wud love im to pieces but them horrid people shud deserve a life in a prison n if i lived near them people i wud take baby p away from them. i wish anibody in the world could bring baby p back to life im reel gunna miss him R.I.P baby p ..xxxxxxxxxx all mi love”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Warwick, Gorseinon

    Sunday, December 07 2008, 5:33PM

    “Every social worker should be accompanied by a minder - an ex police officer or ex soldier who can handle themselves - when making visits to check up on the welfare of children. You can't expect  women, however well trained they are in their jobs, to stand up to drunken brutes and call them liars.These minders should be guaranteed freedom from prosecution if they have to resort to physical action to ensure the safety of themselves, the social worker or to ensure that they child is seen on it's own without any other adults present.But of course, this won't happen because it is too radical - and might work.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Ray Welsby, Clase Morriston

    Saturday, December 06 2008, 7:48PM

    “Swansea social services should now be re- investigated by the govornment, reference the damning report against them in the Aaron Gilbert case, as the same people are still in position. So if Edd Balls the Labour Minister is going to make sure this abuse of children is stopped then he must order a new inquirey into the baby Aaron case and our Swansea MPs must insist on this to make sure that this can not happen again in Swansea.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Clare, Neath

    Saturday, December 06 2008, 7:39PM

    “What happened to Aaron, Baby P and every other child that has or is suffering abuse is horrific. My thoughts are with Aarons dad and innocent suffering relatives, I can not even begin to imgaine what they have gone and are still going through.

    I think the walk should be to raise awareness, ensure that all that can be done by all agencies involved in child protection are doing all they can and remember all children who have suffered. It is heartbreaking and stomach churning to think that there are children still suffering. I hope that the walk will remember all children and possibly help more children in the future. God bless Aaron, Baby P and all others.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters