Protesters warning Swansea biomass plant will be three times Liberty's size

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Profile image for This is SouthWales

This is SouthWales

A SPRAWLING power plant which would billow smoke out across Swansea Bay would be as big as three Liberty Stadiums, campaigners have warned.

The biomass at Kings Dock, Swansea, is still on the cards, despite councillors refusing to give planning permission last year.

The Pontyates tycoon behind the scheme, Clive Hughes, has since lodged an appeal with the Assembly, as well as trying to get the go-ahead for another plant in Kidwelly.

But dumfounded residents and concerned campaign groups have reacted angrily to the appeal — describing the power plant as damaging to the city's £200 million a year tourist trade.

Among those fighting against the plant is Coedbach Action Group chairman's Robin Cammish.

He told marina residents at a public meeting this week they must be prepared to put up a fight at an upcoming public enquiry in May.

"The size and scale of the Swansea plant makes for shocking reading," he said. "If you have driven past the Liberty Stadium, you know how big it is.

"Put those together three times and that the size of the plant. And instead of 60,000 fans, the developer would be employing just 90.

"This public inquiry will run for three weeks, and the Assembly must be able to hear the level of public dissent loud and clear."

Proposals for the 50 megawatt plant have caused controversy ever since they were first unveiled in 2007. It will generate electricity by burning wood-chip, imported from around the globe.

But concerned locals say a power station should not be sited in the regenerated commercial hub of SA1.

Maritime Quarter Residents Association (MQRA) members spoke for over an hour about the issue at their monthly meeting, in Swansea Civic Centre, last Monday evening.

Chairwoman Jan Lewis said: "Placing a power plant so close to people's homes and a valuable commercial area such as SA1, is degeneration and going back to Swansea's past.

"We are talking about a quarter mile long power plant, of which a third will be as high as 15 storeys."

As well as the visual impact, concerns were also been raised about the knock-on effects to the environment.

MRQA say they plan to put a strong case across at the public enquiry.

The deadline for written objections was on January 21.

But an Assembly spokeswoman added: "The person conducting the inquiry will be ask members of the public if they wish to speak.

"People do not have to apply to speak, but they will have to make themselves known at the beginning of the inquiry."

The public inquiry takes place at 10am on May 18, at The Dylan Thomas Centre, Swansea.

6
Tweet this article
Report

6 Comments

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Evan Elpus, Swansea

    Wednesday, March 17 2010, 7:38PM

    “Everyone expects to have power at a flick of a switch, but no one wants a power plant anywhere close to where they live.
    Let's hear some suggestions from the NIMBY's of where they think this plant should be situated.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Philips, Swansea

    Wednesday, March 17 2010, 7:11PM

    “So where does this powerplant go then? In the middle of nowhere? Unlikely. Port Talbot? They just rejected one. Singleton Park? Not likely.

    It's all well and good for people to say NIMBY, but where do you suggest.

    @Andy SA1 - That brown haze over South Asia is about as comparable as comparing a nuclear bomb site to a nuclear power station. Power stations using modern filters are far, far cleaner than forest clearing and cooking fires from peat and jungle wood.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Andy, SA1

    Wednesday, March 17 2010, 6:20PM

    “As a further footnote to my last post below, some study into biomass is worthwhile. Apparently, a recent Swedish study of the giant brown haze that periodically covers large areas in South Asia determined that it had been principally produced by biomass burning. This was published in Science Magazine just last year.

    Do we really want this in Swansea?”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Andy, SA1

    Wednesday, March 17 2010, 6:04PM

    “Slumdog - what nonsense. Yes, I would say this wouldn't I but to spend millions on regenerating a rat-infested docks into a place suitable for people to live and visit only to throw it all away by building this abomination is madness.

    The Marina is a massive tourist draw and is one of the few areas of Swansea that we can actually be proud of outside of Mumbles and the Gower. Says it all that the proposal comes from a 'tycoon' with no interest in the quality of life of the people of Swansea - he's only interested in making money.

    Sadly, the Assembley is hell bent on increasing plants of this type because of its 'green credentials' - despite the fact that the wood to be burned is imported - presumably burning tonnes of fuel in the process. See? Madness!”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by slumdog trust millionaire, landore

    Wednesday, March 17 2010, 4:48PM

    “might be a good way for the residents of the sa1 development to repay the rest of the people of swansea. dont forget, the people of swansea who do not live in the sa1 development area have to pay, and have to continue to pay through the generations, for the upkeep of the sea defences to protect sa1.
    a biomass plant producing energy is one way to placate the masses.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters