Parents speak same language on schools

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
Profile image for This is SouthWales

This is SouthWales

PERHAPS once regarded as a "pointless language", the trend of learning Welsh is growing.

In the past six years alone, Swansea Council has seen a consistent increase in demand for places at Welsh- medium schools.

As of January 2010 there were 1,988 full-time pupils in Welsh-medium primary provision, compared with 1,659 in January 2004, and the demand is projected to continue to increase to 2,719 by September 2016.

David Williams, of Cockett, decided to send his 3-year-old daughter to a Welsh-medium school, despite living closer to a number of English- speaking schools. So what made him chose Llwynderw in West Cross?

"I wanted her to learn a language," he said. "That would be the same in Wales as if we lived abroad, say Spain. Also, learning a language at a young age opens up that side of your brain.

"Research has shown that can create a greater aptitude for other languages later in life.

Pleased

"I suppose there is a tradition of parents thinking their children will get a better education because there will be smaller classes in Welsh schools, prompting parents to chose those over English-medium schools.

"However, I've heard there maybe around 40 children in my daughter's class next year. That news doesn't affect mine and my partner's decision to send her there. We're really pleased with the education she's receiving."

However, Mr Williams said no decision had been made as to whether to send his daughter to a Welsh- medium secondary school.

"We don't know about that yet," he added. Swansea Council has already created more additional Welsh- medium primary places than the original target approved within the Welsh Education Scheme (an original target of 300 additional places by 2011, which was revised to 500 places in the annual monitoring reports).

Should current proposals be approved, which would see a new Welsh- medium school on the Graig Infant School site and increased admission numbers at YGG Pontybrenin, YGG Tirdeunaw and YGG Gellionnen, the authority will have created more than 700 additional places in the areas identified as facing the greatest need.

As of January 2010 there were 2,400 Welsh-medium primary places available, in comparison with 1,876 in January 2004. If the current statutory proposals to create the additional places in Swansea are approved by the Assembly Minister for Education, Leighton Andrews, the number of places available by September 2011 would be 2,727.

A Swansea Council spokesman said: "Careful consideration has been given to the needs of pupils receiving education through both the medium of English and the medium of Welsh.

"This has included an extensive stakeholder engagement as part of the Authority's Quality in Education (QEd) 2020 programme, and the authority is continuing to deliver the priority options identified through this process, as resources allow."

"Recent surveys of parental preferences further support the pressure for Welsh-medium primary places in the broader Morriston area and to the east of the city."

Neath Port Talbot has also commissioned a survey to find out the preferred choice for parents.

Letters

The authority is sending out letters to parents of children up to 3-and- a-half years of age, asking them what their preferred language for learning is when their child starts school.

Mum of two Melissa Griffith has one child already at a Welsh-medium primary school and is keen for her second child to follow in their footsteps. She is urging other parents to fill out the questionnaire.

However, not everybody believes Welsh education is the best route.

Another mum, Gemma Jones, said: "I'm proud to be Welsh and I think there's an increasing benefit to learning Welsh if you want to work in the Welsh public sector, but I'd fear it would put my children at a disadvantage later in their education.

"Would, for example, their written English be up to scratch when they needed it at university?"

Parents, at closure-threatened Graig Infant School in Morriston in particular, said they feared Welsh-medium education was taking precedence over English-medium education.

Parent governor Adrian Smith said: "I have nothing against Welsh-medium education, but under the new plans to turn an empty Graig school into a Welsh school, there will be 15 pupils to a class, but 30-plus in Pentrepoeth."

helen.keates@swwmedia.co.uk

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by laura, swansea

    Wednesday, July 28 2010, 8:06PM

    “The answer to Gemma Jones's question, will her children's written English be up to scratch? the answer is yes. Their English should not suffer. They will learn English from year 3 and continue into comp.

    Both my children went to a Welsh medium school. They were both absolutely fine. Once they learnt to read Welsh books the English was easy. So easy that they both excelled.

    They were taught English from year 3. English language and literature is taught in comp. They both had A's for English GCSE. The eldest had an A at A level. T
    hey both went to University.Neither had any problems with their essays. Spelling and grammar was never as issue.

    Bob Treboeth, let's face it, not all children are capable. How can you possibly say their English will suffer, just because your Grand Children have problems! I know that my children's friends have all achieved good English results. I have work colleague whose children are in Welsh schools and are doing well.

    Putting the children in a Welsh medium school was the best thing we did. The teachers really care. My children were really happy all through school.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by bob, neath

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 6:49PM

    “Both my children attend Welsh Schools - I was unable to as a child due to my locality. Neither my husband or I speak Welsh, we have struggled at times - but with the internet and a good dictionary you can support the children through their education. My daughters GCSE results are out next month - predicted results 10 A's - What ever the results I am so pleased and proud that they attended Welsh School.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by carol griffiths, swansea

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 3:28PM

    “we choose to send our daughter to a welsh medium school due to the fact her father and grand parent's are welsh speaking and only speak english to me. my daughter has come on leaps and bounds with the welsh language. we could have sent her to our local english school but we both felt that we should make the effort to give her the best chance to speak to her dad and grandparents in their own language. we have been slow in the past to accept our welsh language and i for one wish i could speak it as well as my 5 year old dose. she can also write in both language's without any problems. bob of treboeth maybe your son or daughter should have a word with the school. or like us help them to write english at home as well as welsh.a lot of jobs today want you to be able to speak welsh. wish my parents had the though to send us to a welsh medium school.its harder to learn the language when you are older.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Heather, Mumbles

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 1:50PM

    “Wonderful. The Welsh people were never conquered and I'm glad to say that neither will our language be taken.

    Thankfully there are still people out there who can see what a treasure Welsh is. Good for them.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Bob, Treboeth

    Tuesday, July 27 2010, 11:38AM

    “The answer to Gemma Jones's question, will her children's written English be up to scratch?, the answer is no.My four grand- children have been taught in Welsh medium schools and they all have this problem, which is a pity because we are still looking for all the jobs that are supposed to be waiting for Welsh speakers when they leave school.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters