NHS worker's bullying victory

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, February 28, 2009
Profile image for This is SouthWales

This is SouthWales

A HOSPITAL employee has been told she can expect a six figure pay-out after winning her case for damages after being bullied at work.

Nanette Bowen, from Llanelli, suffered a nervous breakdown and was unable to return to work after being harassed over a three year period, according to her solicitors.

Hywel Dda NHS Trust has now been told to dig deep for damages by her union, who helped Mrs Bowen bring the case to Swansea County Court.

The 55-year-old information manager had worked at Prince Philip Hospital for more than 28 years, working her way up the ranks, from porter to information manager, reporting directly to the chief executive.

In 2000, Eric Lewis became her boss, following a merger of Llanelli and Dinefwr trusts to become Carmarthenshire NHS Trust (now part of Hywel Dda NHS Trust).

According to statements issued by her union, Unison, and her solicitors, Thompsons, Mrs Bowen's life became hell over the next three years.

They claimed Mr Lewis was aggressive towards her, made sexual innuendos and banned her from attending meetings vital to her job.

She was signed off sick with stress and suffered panic attacks. At one point she was rushed to hospital with a suspected heart attack.

Mrs Bowen, who had been the main breadwinner in the family, said: "The NHS was my life. I had always felt great loyalty to the trust and worked to the best of my ability in everything I did. I feel bitterly let down by the trust, which did not do its best to support me when I needed it most.

"My life has been ruined by what I went through during those three years.

"At this stage, I cannot contemplate returning to any form of work and I am still receiving counselling to help me control my panic attacks. Without the support of my family and colleagues, I would not be here now."

Dave Galligan, Unison's head of health in Wales, said: "It is disgraceful that this bullying and harassment continued for so long and led to a severe breakdown. Despite her complaints, nothing was done to improve her situation. As a result Mrs Bowen has suffered terribly and the NHS has lost a skilled and dedicated worker.

"This case is a warning to employers that they need to listen to their employees' concerns and act sooner rather than later, or face the consequences."

A ruling on the level of compensation is expected over the next few weeks.

Mr Galligan added: "It's going to be a substantial, probably a six figure settlement. It is deserved, because not only was this a particularly bad case, it was badly handled over a period of time."

A spokeswoman for the trust said: "Hywel Dda NHS Trust does not condone bullying of any kind and policies and procedures are in place to deal with any allegations of inappropriate behaviour.

"Since this case, the former Carmarthenshire NHS Trust, now part of Hywel Dda NHS Trust, reviewed systems relating to workplace health and is now identifying any additional training requirements to ensure that the issues raised in this type of case are managed appropriately for the future."

Mr Lewis declined to comment.

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Florentina Rapanut, Colchester

    Tuesday, July 28 2009, 6:49PM

    “Well done to you Mrs. Bowen.I want to have contact with you coz at present im bullied by my ward manager and my matron and some of the sisters due to injury at work. Im suffering from panic attacks and insomnia. I have palpitations and high blood pressure.Im horrified and can trust anybody. Please get in touch with me.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Terry, Llanelli

    Tuesday, March 03 2009, 3:59PM

    “I'm thrilled that Mrs Bowen won her case she deserves it after the hell she's been through. The bullying is still rife in the Health Service usually by managers and is a disgrace. People are afraid to speak up in case they lose their jobs but it should be the bully's who lose their jobs”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Ben, Prince Phillip

    Sunday, March 01 2009, 1:39PM

    “One can only hope that the Trust take heed of this decision. There are many nurses who are bullied by consultants, sometimes in front of patients. Senior management know of these cases as they are reported to them. Unfortunately, they turn a blind eye. Staff go off with stress-related illnesses and are then hauled before HR to explain why they had time off. It's about time senior management stood by their committed members of staff and weed out the bullies!”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by SS.72, llanelli

    Saturday, February 28 2009, 4:52PM

    “Well done to Mrs Bowen. She had the dertermination to carry it through. So many put up with buillying in the work place, and bullys get away with it. Many congratulations on winning. She should be very proud of herself. Hope she gets every penny and more.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by amina, swansea

    Saturday, February 28 2009, 3:34PM

    “It is interesting to see the level of activity and acomplishement that Unison and their lawyers have allegedly acheived in this case. It is a shame that other cases of bullying & harrassment in the NHS do not get the same level of skill and committment from these authorities despite having paid their union contributions.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters