Husband to plead for his wife's life

Trusted article source icon
Monday, November 03, 2008
Profile image for This is SouthWales

This is SouthWales

THE husband of a dying Swansea kidney cancer sufferer will tomorrow plead with health bosses to prolong his wife's life.

Ronald Shaddick has told of his family's anguish after Swansea Local Health Board (LHB) refused to fund a life-prolonging drug for his wife, Hendrieka.

He attacked the decision, saying: "It seems cost is more important than life."

Grandmother-of-two Mrs Shaddick, of Heol-y-Twyn, was first diagnosed with kidney cancer in May this year.

The 70-year-old's consultant at Singleton Hospital, Professor John Wagstaff, said Sutent would be her best chance of life. But the LHB refused to fund the treatment — which costs around £30,000 a year for each patient.

Mrs Shaddick's daughter, Deborah Walters, described how her family had been forced to watch her beloved mum waste away.

"She has gone down from a size 20 to a size 10 in five months because she cannot eat," she said.

"Professor Wagstaff said he cannot give my mum the drug, as it has got to go in front of the local health board."

The family's appeal against the decision is expected to be heard tomorrow.

Ms Walters added: "The cancer is just eating away at everything. She deserves more than this — she deserves a chance."

She said Sutent was the family's only hope of having more time together.

"My mum and dad have been married for 48 years and to see your parents crying is heartbreaking," said Ms Walters.

Mr Shaddick added: "We just cannot go on like this. Sutent is not going to cure the cancer but it will prolong life and that is what we are looking for."

Professor Wagstaff told the Post that trials have shown Sutent to double life expectancy in kidney cancer patients, compared to other drugs.

Referring to the LHB policy of funding the drug only in 'exceptional' cases, Professor Wagstaff said: "Why does a patient have to be exceptional to get treatment on the NHS?"

A spokeswoman for Swansea LHB said: "The provision of treatments locally are in line with national guidance issued by organisations such as the National Institute for clinical evidence (Nice) and the All Wales Medicines Strategy Group (Awmsg)."

She pointed out that in August 2007, the Health Minister formally approved the decision of the Awmsg that Sutent should not be recommended for use within NHS Wales for the treatment of advanced and/or metastatic renal cell carcinoma.

"This drug is currently in the process of review by Nice," she added.

9
Tweet this article
Report

9 Comments

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Linda Williams, Swansea

    Friday, November 07 2008, 9:34AM

    “I think it's terrible that they will not provide the drug that will prolong her life a little longer. My heart goes out to you and your family. God Bless you all.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by c.ricketts, swansea

    Wednesday, November 05 2008, 8:49AM

    “Why don`t the NHS put a small charge back on prescriptions (£1) and stop handing out prescriptions for paracetamol, vaseline etc., products that are available cheaply and put this money towards funding drugs for people that really need it!
    Thinking of you & your family at this hard time”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by jayne, swansea

    Tuesday, November 04 2008, 6:03PM

    “mr stone has hit the nail on the head!! why do we pay national insurance if we cannot use it when we need it! life should be the priority.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by Clive stone, Witney, Oxon

    Tuesday, November 04 2008, 10:04AM

    “Hendrieka, I really feel for you and your family and hope that you have some support during this dreadful time. I also have kidney cancer and am Chair of a support group (FROG) here in Oxon. Our membership is increasing now with 38 patients. Oxon PCT have only funded 2 out of 24 requests for Sutent. We also have a campaign group for Sutent, (Justice for Kidney Cancer Patients) and demonstrated at NICE HQ in August. We will keep up the pressure on everyone's behalf but it is not easy taking on the NHS,which needs radical change to stop them wasting further taxpayers money on countless layers of bureaucracy. We need to make the countless pen pushers and govt ministers become accountable.
    We are one of the most highly taxed countries and yet our five year cancer survival rates is one of the worst. What is the point of all the research when we cannot have the drugsthat are available in Rumania and globally in many other countries?
    It is high time that the ordinary citizens of this country had the healthcare system that they deserve after a lifetime of taxation. The thoughts of all of us at FROG are with you and countless others across the country in your fight for fair treatment.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthWales

    by carol, Swansea

    Monday, November 03 2008, 7:52PM

    “I am just hoping you will pass on the following information Kate Spall website
    pamelanorthcottfund.org.uk
    Kate has had a great success at appeals for refused funding by nhs.
    I Mrs Shaddick has an appeal tomorrow, but she can have another.
    Our family lost someome special last month, we went through exactly the same
    Thanking you, kind regards Carol”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters