GCSE grade change 'stopped boy getting apprenticeship'
A HEADTEACHER says a pupil has been told he cannot start an apprenticeship as a result of changes in the way GCSEs have been graded.
Sue Hollister, head teacher of Cefn Hengoed Community School, said the experience of the former pupil was just one example of how young people have lost out following the row over GCSE students being awarded lower grades than expected.
-

Head teacher Sue Hollister
Welsh Education Minister Leighton Andrews said hundreds of pupils had been the victims of an "injustice" after exam boards changed their grading systems earlier this year.
And Ms Hollister says her staff, who work with moderator AQA, are still dealing with the fall-out.
Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk
View detailsOur heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.
Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk
Contact: 01858 468192
Valid until: Sunday, May 26 2013
She said: "It affects hundreds of Welsh pupils here in our little corner of Swansea, for example. Last summer's lovely Year 11 pupils, who worked so hard for the great results they achieved, are returning from the colleges to seek our advice on resits as it affects their ability to register for AS courses. I have even heard of a former pupil who cannot start his apprenticeship due to getting a D instead of a predicted C.
"Paradoxically, one of our pupils missed a grade C by one mark according to the summer AQA gradings yet achieved grade A in history and RE, both subjects which require and demonstrate a significant ability to read and write to a complex level to deliver such high grades.
"This is all about young people, their hopes and dreams and also the confidence they are having eroded by a system in which they had placed their trust.
"As a parent myself, I feel for their parents and empathise with their worry and would want to reassure them that we are doing all we can to make our case and fight for what we believe was rightly theirs to achieve.
"The bottom line is there were 15 marks' difference in what you needed to get a C in January or last summer to what you need this summer. And that is unjust."
The Welsh Government is the exam regulator for Wales, while in England exams are regulated by Ofqual.
Ofqual acknowledged grade boundaries had changed part way through the year, but stood by the new June grading system.
Mr Andrews has said he wanted GCSE English papers regraded after publishing the findings of a review by regulatory officials, putting him at loggerheads with his Westminster counterpart Michael Gove.
nino.williams@swwmedia.co.uk
01792 514624




Comments
by Walesforever
Tuesday, September 18 2012, 11:08PM
“Just an aside to the discussion. ( Apart from the fact that you sit an exam and either get the required mark and pass, or you don't and fail, no matter how " lovely" you are ). I seem to remember some years ago that there were league tables published and that Cefn Hengoed came top in one. Absenteeism.
No doubt Mrs Hollister has sorted this problem out, and now that the majority of her pupils attend regularly, she expects that they should all recieve a qualification based on attendance.”
by gorseboy
Tuesday, September 18 2012, 8:10PM
“Is this silly topic still doing the rounds?
Teachers become clairvoyants? Exam Boards move the goalposts? Only definate is pupils not working hard enough to get a good mark.
I sat my exams in 1959 when it was pass or fail no in between,let's get back there for sanity sake!”
by carpmeister
Tuesday, September 18 2012, 6:56PM
“It's no wonder that Welsh education is lagging behind Europe, and even England, when you look at the totally incompetent buffoon Leighton Andrews. He is totally clueless about what needs to be done, Welsh Labour, just like Labour in England have been moving the goalposts for exam results for years to make it look like students are doing better than they really are. So much so that a place at university has been devalued by making exams so easy that practically anyone can go, rather than the top students who fully deserve to go. Not every student is university material, and nor should they be. Until Wales gets an education minister that knows what he/she is doing Wales will carry on falling behind everyone else.”
by Penyfai
Tuesday, September 18 2012, 10:17AM
“Ah the old epistemlogical claim of the practical arts and the validity of learning styles. Vocational learning and academic learning - what have they got in common? They are both forms of learning. The problem with "comp" school is the abundance of coercion - you must study this and that in silos. WHY? Why not create authentic learning environments and ditch the silo mentality? Problem - UNIONS!! They just don't do change.”
by Neathboy234
Monday, September 17 2012, 11:05AM
“brochadav vocational training does take place at most comp schools. Children of lesser abilities are shipped out a few days a week to local firms for them to gain experience. Personally I would rather more time was spent educating these children in the core subjects, this will be of greater use throughout their lives. I think it's just wrong to right children off as a failure at a young age.”
by brochadav
Monday, September 17 2012, 10:18AM
“Our son is 4 years old and I have no confidence our education system will be good enough for his needs. His current school is fantastic but when he moves to comp is when the problems will begin.
I see a lot of what our children are taught as pointless and careers advice could be a lot better too.
If children are not good academically why insist they learn things of no use to them, why not start vocational training at school. Yes it would be expensive but leaving school with a skill is better than a row of D's, or lower, on a piece of paper.
I honestly believe Andrews is doing what he thinks best and I have serious doubts about Gove. The fact is though, our children are being seriously let down. us parents have to speak up, we also have to give what help we can to our children and not just rely on school. Learning to read, write and count can be started at home before school, any headstart is better than none.”
by Neathboy234
Monday, September 17 2012, 9:39AM
“Personaly I think Wales should stick with the GCSE, it's an internationally recognized exam. As Penyfai pointed out to us "The GCSE is offered the world over. In fact the the best schooling system in the world offers GCSEs". If the English want to go off on a limp and change for the sake of change let them i say.
NB No doubt in 2015 when Labour gain control of the English parliament it will all be up in the air again. I of course say English parliament as increasingly Westminster only deals with English matters, IE Health and Education plus all the other devolved areas's”
by Penyfai
Monday, September 17 2012, 8:58AM
“Ah Greta - an alternative opinion challenging the medocrity of the status quo must be "bias or grudge" LOL. Good luck with that! As for O levels - I am not obsessed with GCSEs or O levels. I do not support the damage being done to children's education in Wales either. Independence or lack of it will be fun to watch, just "keep on keeping on". Wales' education system is letting children down whilst nationalism is the priority. But hey ho you keep comparing yourself to England if that what truly floats your boat!”
by GretaCarbo
Sunday, September 16 2012, 7:28PM
“Neathboy234
Scheduled for intro in autumn 2015.
Gove has the backing of Clegg.
Just where our current Sec of State for Education will be in 3 years time is anybody's guess but, I would prefer him to be packed back into the suitcase with Archie Andrews and the other vent dummies.”
by Neathboy234
Sunday, September 16 2012, 1:50PM
“Penyfai interesting news from England(u know the place i'm obsessed with lol). It now looks as if this week they will announce the end of the GCSE, and replace it with the old ) level. If the GCSE is so good and offered all over the world, then why are they getting rid of it. One thing it will do is increase the differences between England and wales, music to the ears of all Plaid supporters i'm sure”